Many years ago I bought a used Digitech 1101 preamp and some of the knobs were missing. I did eventually get original Digitech knobs from the manufacturer, but that took a while. In the mean time I designed all the knobs for the preamp, which mimiced their original design.
I once printed these knobs in TPU, but you could use a harder plastic if you like. If I was to print these again I'd most likely use TPU and use a high infill so that it doesn't feel squeeshy. I imagine that these would work for other electronics as well.
The author marked this model as their own original creation.